ad
ad
Topview AI logo

Huawei Celia VS Google Assistant VS Samsung Bixby - Voice Assistants Battle

Science & Technology

Introduction

In this quick battle of voice assistants, we compare Huawei's Celia, Google Assistant, and Samsung's Bixby. The evaluation is based on several simple commands to see which voice assistant performs better in various tasks. Our test devices include the Huawei P40 Pro, Google Pixel 4 XL, and Samsung Galaxy S20. Below are the results of our tests across several command types:

Weather Inquiry

We started by asking about the weather:

  1. Celia: "What's the weather today?" – Celia struggled to provide a straightforward answer.
  2. Google Assistant: Delivered a concise forecast detailing rain and snow, including highs and lows for today and tomorrow.
  3. Bixby: Provided a detailed weather forecast as well, but with excessive detail about snowfall.

For tomorrow’s weather, both Google Assistant and Bixby performed well, while Celia lagged behind.

Setting Alarms

Next, we tested the ability to set alarms:

  1. Celia: "Set alarm for 4 PM" – Successfully set the alarm.
  2. Google Assistant: Also set the alarm without any issues.
  3. Bixby: Had no problem setting the alarm either but was slightly less intuitive in responses.

Deleting alarms was similarly straightforward for Google and Bixby, while Celia managed to execute the command effectively as well.

Reminders

When it came to reminders, we tested by asking to remember to close a door:

  1. Celia: Confirmed the reminder but not very intuitively.
  2. Google Assistant: Handled it efficiently, recalling the reminder later upon request.
  3. Bixby: Similar to Celia, but more tedious about the reminder process.

User Interface Functions

We then asked to enable dark mode and change font size:

  1. Celia: Enabled dark mode with ease.
  2. Google Assistant: Also enabled dark mode effortlessly.
  3. Bixby: Encountered issues trying to change font size, indicating limited functionality.

Telecommunication

In terms of making calls:

  1. Celia: Called without hesitation.
  2. Google Assistant: Also initiated the call quickly.
  3. Bixby: A little slow, asking for clarification but ultimately successful.

Emails and Notifications

Next, we checked emails and notifications:

  1. Celia: Could not interface properly.
  2. Google Assistant: Read notifications effortlessly and interactively.
  3. Bixby: Provided basic notifications without deeper interaction.

For navigation, we asked all three to navigate to Berlin:

  1. Celia: Failed to initiate navigation effectively.
  2. Google Assistant: Directly began navigation.
  3. Bixby: Opened Google Maps but required manual initiation from the user.

Memory and Shopping Lists

When testing memory and shopping lists:

  1. Celia: Struggled to recall items effectively.
  2. Google Assistant: Handled lists with precision and easy recall.
  3. Bixby: Did not support shopping lists, leading to poor performance.

Miscellaneous Queries

For general queries and calculations, here’s how they fared:

  1. Celia: Had trouble with direct questions.
  2. Google Assistant: Provided accurate answers.
  3. Bixby: Also provided answers but lacked engagement.

Conclusion

Based on our comprehensive tests, Google Assistant clearly outperformed both Huawei's Celia and Samsung's Bixby. Bixby takes second place with reasonable capabilities, while Celia falls behind, often struggling with basic tasks. Huawei’s voice assistant shows potential for improvement with regular updates, particularly with app control issues.

In the battle of voice assistants, Google remains the dominant choice, followed by Samsung and then Huawei.

Keywords

  • Huawei Celia
  • Google Assistant
  • Samsung Bixby
  • Voice Assistants
  • Weather Inquiry
  • Setting Alarms
  • Reminders
  • Navigation
  • Notifications
  • App Control

FAQ

Q: Which voice assistant is the most effective?
A: Based on the comparisons, Google Assistant is the most effective voice assistant.

Q: How does Huawei's Celia perform compared to Samsung's Bixby?
A: Celia struggles with basic tasks, while Bixby is more competent but still less effective than Google Assistant.

Q: Can all three assistants set alarms?
A: Yes, all three assistants can set alarms, but their responsiveness may differ.

Q: Why does Celia perform poorly in navigation?
A: Celia's inability to initiate navigation effectively is primarily due to app control issues with Google applications.

Q: What are the strengths of Google Assistant?
A: Google Assistant excels in various tasks including weather inquiries, reminders, navigation, and general conversation.