Living Room Tussle Lands Ladies in Court! | Part 1

Living Room Tussle Lands Ladies in Court! | Part 1

Incident Overview

In a recent episode of Judge Judy, the court dealt with a case where former friends Denise Patton and Deja Kelly found themselves embroiled in a legal battle due to a heated altercation in Patton's apartment. The event, which took place on April 4th, stemmed from ongoing animosity between the two women, exacerbated by Kelly's uninvited presence in Patton's home.

Testimonies and Claims

Plaintiff: Denise Patton

Denise Patton, the complainant, stated that she had made it clear that Deja Kelly was not welcome in her apartment. On April 4th, when Patton returned home to find Kelly there with her cousin, hostility erupted, leading to a physical fight during which several items in the apartment were damaged. Patton accused Kelly of initiating the altercation and demanded compensation for the broken items.

Defendant: Deja Kelly

Deja Kelly, on the other hand, claimed she was an invited guest of Patton's cousin and did not expect Patton to be home. According to Kelly, the conflict began when Patton arrived, became hostile, and slapped Kelly’s phone out of her hand. Kelly then picked up the phone, which Patton allegedly threw into the toilet, leading to a fight where everyone in the apartment got involved.

Witness: Noria

Noria, who was Kelly's girlfriend and Patton's cousin at the time of the incident, provided a slightly different account. According to Noria, Patton did not slap the phone out of Kelly’s hand or throw it in the toilet. Instead, she claimed Patton threw the phone out the door, where it landed on the concrete and broke.

Court Proceedings

Judge Judy systematically questioned both parties and the witness to piece together the sequence of events. Noria's testimony seemed to align more closely with the physical evidence, which showed a phone damaged by impact, not water damage.

Conclusion

The episode highlighted the breakdown of a former friendship exacerbated by a moment of intense conflict. Judge Judy recommended resolving their issues out of court and emphasized sticking to the factual evidence presented.

Keywords

• Judge Judy
• Denise Patton
• Deja Kelly
• Physical fight
• Apartment damage
• Broken phone
• Hostility
• Legal dispute
• Witness testimony
• Court case

FAQ

Q: Who filed the complaint in this case? A: The complaint was filed by Denise Patton.

Q: What was the primary cause of the altercation on April 4th? A: The altercation was primarily caused by Deja Kelly’s uninvited presence in Denise Patton’s apartment.

Q: What item was at the center of the physical fight? A: A phone that was allegedly slapped out of Kelly’s hand and later thrown, leading to its damage.

Q: Who provided the testimony as a witness in this case? A: The witness testimony was provided by Noria, Kelly’s girlfriend and Patton’s cousin.

Q: Did the physical evidence align more with Patton's or Kelly's version of the events? A: The physical evidence (a cracked but not waterlogged phone) aligned more with Noria’s testimony.