The Happiest Grandpa Eats Bacon ?

Introduction

A new free AI video tool has recently been released. When I was experimenting with this tool, known as Gen 3, something else came to my attention: Gen 3 image uploading was also launched. I decided to put this to the test by comparing it with another AI tool called Luma.

Comparing Luma and Gen 3

To give these tools a fair test, I came up with this creative prompt: "The happiest Grandpa holds bacon." Here's how each of the tools performed:

Luma

The result from Luma was incredibly happy, albeit with a quirky twist. The grandpa appeared delighted, but the bacon turned out weirdly stretched. Here's my observation:

• The happy expression is spot-on.
• The bacon is stretched in an odd manner.

Gen 3

On the other hand, Gen 3 produced a fascinating result. The facial details of the grandpa were quite precise, and initially, the hands looked almost normal—but wait, there was a double finger! Here’s a breakdown:

• The face is really well-drawn.
• The hands almost look normal, but there's a double finger.

Testing a Long Prompt

I decided to push these tools further with a more complex prompt: "The happiest Grandpa holds bacon, then he turns into liquid metal."

Luma

Luma attempted to meet the challenge but missed some aspects. The grandpa was holding what appeared to be chocolate cake rather than bacon, and while there was an element that represented liquid metal, it wasn’t entirely coherent.

Observations:

• The grandpa is holding what looks like chocolate cake.
• There is some representation of liquid metal.

Gen 3

Gen 3 impressed me again. This time, it started with a straightforward image of bacon in a hand, but with sunlight in the background, it transitioned into liquid metal, eventually morphing into a grandpa. That was stunning!

Observations:

• The image started simple with bacon in hand.
• The background sunlight added a realistic touch.
• The transition to liquid metal and then to grandpa was executed well.

Conclusion

Both tools have their strengths and weaknesses. Luma needs a bit more refinement on specific aspects like object consistency and transformation, whereas Gen 3 demonstrated a more detailed and dynamic transformation, though it still has minor issues like extra fingers.