The Ultimate Voice Assistant Battle.
Science & Technology
The Ultimate Voice Assistant Battle
The competition between voice assistants has become fierce, and we're comparing Apple Siri, Google Assistant, Amazon's Alexa, and Samsung's Bixby to determine who reigns supreme. With 65 carefully selected questions, we'll find out which assistant can make your life the easiest.
Math Questions in the Study
- What's two plus two minus one?
- What's 104 plus 64 times 14?
- Divide that by three.
- Multiply that by seven.
- Convert 6 cups to milliliters.
- Split a bill of 69 pounds 42 between three people.
All assistants quickly handled these basic math tasks.
Turning Off Smart Light Bulbs
Each assistant can turn off a compatible smart light bulb with the command "Turn off the light." Surprisingly, Alexa performed best in this round.
Device Control in the Bedroom
Commands tested:
- Turn off Bluetooth.
- Increase screen brightness by 20 percent.
- Change my wallpaper.
- Turn on dark mode.
- Take a selfie / picture in 5 seconds.
- How much battery do I have left?
Google Assistant excelled due to its design for device control, making up some ground.
Smart Doorbell Check
Using a Ring doorbell:
- Who's at the door?
Siri could not directly access Ring doorbells but scored points for compatibility with other smart doorbells.
Internet Queries While Cooking
Commands tested:
- What's the weather like today?
- What will be the highest temperature today?
- What will the weather be like on Tuesday next week?
- Should I take an umbrella with me today?
- What song is this?
When it came to controlling specific smart plugs and kettles, all assistants handled commands efficiently.
Deeper Internet Queries
- How old is Rick Astley?
- How many number one songs does he have?
- Is he playing any concerts soon?
- When is the next Avengers movie due to be released? and more.
Google led in answering complex internet queries involving several steps of information retrieval.
Third-Party App Controls
Commands tested:
- Open the app store.
- Set an alarm for 7 am.
- Show me photos from 2021.
- Which of them were taken in the United States?
- Show me a recipe for passion fruit pie.
- Play Stranger Things season 4 on Netflix.
- Send a tweet.
Google Assistant and Alexa excelled with comprehensive third-party app control.
Smart Vacuum Control
Command: "Vacuum up the kitchen, please"
Google Assistant, Bixby, and Alexa successfully navigated and vacuumed specific rooms. Siri could only start vacuuming.
Advanced App Commands
- Send an email to Mrs. Hughes.
- Search eBay for Nintendo GameCube.
- Translate the following.
Complexity in routine tasks saw Bixby performing extremely well.
Human Interaction
- What's my name?
- Call me boss man.
- Tell me a joke / dad joke.
- Remember that my keys are under the mat.
- Forget everything I told you today.
Routine Management
Routines tested:
- Detect when home past 5 PM.
- Activate driving apps when connecting to car Bluetooth.
- Dismiss alarm to trigger news.
- Morning routines on command.
Google and Bixby impressed with advanced routine handling. Bixby's capability in managing bad habits stands out.
The winner of the best voice assistant is Google Assistant.
Keywords
- Voice assistants
- Apple Siri
- Google Assistant
- Amazon Alexa
- Samsung Bixby
- Smart home control
- Device control
- Internet queries
- Third-party apps
- Routines
FAQ
Q1: Which voice assistant is the best overall? A1: Google Assistant is considered the best overall due to its comprehensive device control, internet query response, and compatibility with third-party apps and smart routines.
Q2: Can all voice assistants control smart home devices? A2: Yes, all voice assistants can control compatible smart home devices, such as light bulbs and smart plugs.
Q3: How do the assistants fare in basic math tasks? A3: All voice assistants handle basic math tasks efficiently.
Q4: Which assistant performs best with smart doorbells? A4: Google Assistant, Alexa, and Bixby can check who is at the door using a Ring doorbell, while Siri is compatible with other smart doorbells.
Q5: How well do the assistants handle third-party app commands? A5: Google Assistant and Alexa excel at controlling third-party apps like setting alarms, opening app stores, and playing media content.
Q6: Can these assistants manage routines and automation effectively? A6: Yes, Google Assistant and Bixby are particularly strong with routines, while Siri and Alexa also support basic routine management.
Q7: Which assistant offers the best human interaction? A7: Google Assistant provides natural and effective human interaction, closely followed by Siri and Alexa. Bixby performs well but could be more intuitive in natural interaction.